America.co emblemAmerica.co

Independent America

Compare candidates beyond party labels

Compare candidates side by side using their proposals, voting records, costs, and dated sources. Use the private worksheet to evaluate the same issue for both.

The short answer

Compare one proposal on the same issue for each candidate. Check what the office can do, what the candidate has said or done in a dated public record, and who would have to approve and pay for the proposal. Two candidates may share an outcome while differing on cost, authority, and how they plan to deliver it.

Open the side-by-side worksheet ↓

Start with the powers of the office

A legislator, mayor, school-board member, and executive have different authority. First identify the decisions this office controls. Then separate a candidate’s own proposal from a promise that depends on other bodies, a budget vote, or a change in law.

Start with your state or local election office to confirm who is on the ballot. Choose one issue and write the same specific question for both candidates. For a local race, use the office’s published powers, budgets, and meeting minutes. For Congress, use dated roll-call votes and bill text.

Make an evidence table

Use columns for the candidate’s own statement, the proposed mechanism, a dated source, estimated cost if available, prior actions, and unanswered questions. Official voting records and public campaign-finance disclosures are useful inputs, not complete judgments of a person.

Leave an empty cell empty when evidence is missing. A campaign’s silence is different from an explicit position, and a donation does not by itself establish a corrupt relationship.

U.S. House — Roll-call votes ↗ · U.S. Senate — Votes ↗ · FEC — Browse campaign finance data ↗

Compare trade-offs and delivery

Ask what the proposal would replace, who would implement it, how success would be measured, and what could go wrong. Look for a timeline and a path from election to action. A promise with a responsible institution and a measurable outcome is easier to revisit later.

Your final choice can reflect your values. The comparison should still let another reader see the evidence, recognize uncertainty, and reach a different conclusion without needing a different set of facts.

GAO — Performance measurement and evaluation ↗

Make it useful

Your next steps

  1. Choose the office and three specific questions.
  2. Collect equivalent primary evidence for every candidate.
  3. Record missing answers and revisit commitments after the election.
Build a private commitment tracker →

Compare two candidates side by side

Use one issue at a time and cite a dated source for each claim. Your entries stay in this browser. Download your notes to keep a copy.

Candidate A
Candidate B

Common questions

Should I ignore party entirely?

No label has to be ignored. The point is to add direct evidence so a label is not your only information.

Does this guide recommend a candidate?

No. It offers a consistent comparison process, not a partisan ranking.

Follow the source trail

Source links reviewed November 14, 2026. Original worksheets and evaluation questions are America.co guidance; they are not government instructions.

This guide uses AI-assisted drafting and links the underlying sources. It has not been presented as expert-reviewed advice. Read our editorial approach. Send a correction with the source and passage.